Second Liens and HELOCs in Short Sales: How to Get to Yes
Discover how to navigate second liens and HELOCs in short sales effectively. Learn strategies to secure approvals and achieve the best recovery for all parties involved.
Managing Earnest Money in Short Sales: What Buyers Need to Know
Learn how to manage earnest money effectively in short sales to protect your deposit. Understand key contingencies and best practices to minimize financial risks.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Managing Earnest Money in Short Sales: What Buyers Need to Know
When purchasing a home through a short sale, one of the most important financial considerations is how your earnest money deposit will be handled. While earnest money serves the same fundamental purpose in short sales as in traditional transactions, the unique nature of short sales introduces several complexities that buyers must understand.
What is Earnest Money and Why It Matters in Short Sales
Earnest money is a deposit made by a buyer to demonstrate their serious intention to purchase a property. In a short sale, this deposit plays a particularly important role:
- It demonstrates to the seller your commitment to the purchase
- It signals to the lender that the contract has a reasonable chance of closing
- It establishes your credibility as a buyer in a transaction that will require patience and persistence
The typical earnest money deposit is around 1% of the purchase price, though this can vary based on local market conditions and the property's value. In competitive markets, a larger earnest money deposit might help your offer stand out among multiple bids.
The Timeline Challenge: When Deposits Are Made vs. When Approvals Come
One of the most challenging aspects of short sales is the disconnect between when you make your earnest money deposit and when the transaction actually receives lender approval:
- Your earnest money deposit is typically made within 1-3 days after the seller accepts your offer
- However, lender approval for the short sale may take 60-120 days or even longer
- During this extended period, your deposit remains in escrow, essentially "locked up"
This creates a significant timing risk for buyers. Your funds could be held for months while you wait for a decision that might ultimately be negative. This is why proper contingencies in your contract are absolutely essential.
Protecting Your Deposit: Critical Contingencies
To protect your earnest money in a short sale transaction, ensure your purchase agreement includes these key contingencies:
1. Short Sale Approval Contingency
This is the most important protection in a short sale. This contingency specifies that if the lender does not approve the short sale, or approves it with terms different from what you agreed to with the seller, you can walk away with your earnest money returned.
2. Inspection Contingency
Unlike traditional transactions where you might wait for loan approval before conducting inspections, in short sales you should complete your inspection shortly after the contract is signed. This prevents you from waiting months only to discover deal-breaking property issues.
3. Financing Contingency
This allows you to recover your deposit if you're unable to secure financing. In short sales, this is particularly important as your financing options or personal financial situation might change during the lengthy approval process.
4. Timeline Contingency
Consider including language that allows you to recover your deposit if lender approval takes longer than a specified period (often 60-90 days). This prevents your deposit from being tied up indefinitely.
Where Is Your Money Held?
In a short sale, your earnest money deposit is typically held by:
- The real estate brokerage (usually the listing brokerage) in an escrow account
- A third-party escrow company
- An attorney's escrow account
Never give your earnest money directly to the seller under any circumstances. Ensure the funds are held by a licensed and reputable third party.
Common Earnest Money Problems in Short Sales
Several issues commonly arise with earnest money in short sales:
Dispute Over Contingency Timelines
In traditional sales, contingencies have clear deadlines (e.g., 10 days for inspection). In short sales, these timelines can become confusing—do they start when the seller accepts the offer or when the lender approves the short sale? Your contract should clearly address this.
Buyer's Remorse During Long Waits
The extended timeline of short sales gives buyers plenty of time to second-guess their decision. However, walking away without a contingency being triggered will likely result in forfeiting your earnest money.
Changing Market Conditions
During a lengthy short sale process, market conditions might change significantly. If prices drop and you try to renegotiate after lender approval, you might risk your deposit if your contract doesn't allow for this.
Best Practices for Managing Earnest Money in Short Sales
Agent addendum: EM clause library and brokerage variations
- Refundability until approval
- “Earnest money is fully refundable for any reason until written short sale approval is delivered and accepted by both parties.”
- Second deposit on approval
- “Buyer shall deposit an additional $[X] within 3 business days of short sale approval.”
- Clock alignment
- “All inspection, appraisal, and financing timelines toll during lender review and restart upon delivery of written approval.”
- Time‑out safe harbor
- “If no written approval by [Day 75] absent mutual written extension, buyer may cancel and EM shall be returned in full.”
Notes
- Some states require escrow‑holder specific language or attorney escrow; align with your broker and state forms
- In MLSs with standard short sale addenda, mirror the exact refundability language to avoid conflicts
Dispute prevention checklist (agent)
- Provide wire verification instructions in writing and by phone to a known number
- Keep a shared dates log: offer, EM received, submissions, approval milestones
- Send weekly status emails to buyer with EM status, clocks, and next steps
How Practices Vary by Agent, Brokerage, and State
Short sale earnest money handling is not one‑size‑fits‑all. Specifics can vary based on:
- Agent and team practice
- Brokerage escrow policies
- State laws, standard forms, and whether attorneys or escrow companies hold funds
Use short sale addenda and clear contract language to ensure the buyer’s earnest money is refundable for any reason until the lender’s short sale approval is issued and accepted. Always align with your supervising broker and your state’s approved forms.
See the companion advise for agents on structuring primary and backup offers, earnest money, and timelines: How to Handle Offers on Short Sales: Primary, Backups, and Earnest Money
1. Time Your Inspections Properly
Complete your home inspection within days of contract acceptance rather than waiting for lender approval. This allows you to identify any deal-breaking issues before your earnest money has been held for months.
2. Verify All Wire Instructions
Real estate transactions are frequent targets for wire fraud. Always verify wire instructions by calling your agent or escrow officer at a known phone number before sending your earnest money.
3. Document Everything
Keep detailed records of all communications related to contingencies and timelines. If a dispute arises about your earnest money, documentation will be your best defense.
4. Work with Experienced Professionals
Short sales are complex transactions with many pitfalls. Work with a real estate agent and attorney who have specific experience with short sales and understand how to protect your earnest money.
What Happens to Earnest Money at Closing
If your short sale successfully closes:
- Your earnest money is applied toward your down payment and closing costs
- It will be reflected on your Closing Disclosure or HUD-1 Settlement Statement
- No additional action is typically required on your part
When Disputes Arise
If a dispute arises over your earnest money:
- The holder of the funds (escrow company, brokerage, or attorney) typically cannot release the money without agreement from both parties or a court order
- Mediation is often the first step in resolving earnest money disputes
- If mediation fails, the dispute may require arbitration or court action
- In some cases, the costs of pursuing legal action may exceed the earnest money amount
Conclusion
Managing earnest money in short sales requires careful attention to contract details, contingencies, and timelines. By understanding the unique challenges of short sales and implementing proper protections, buyers can pursue these potentially valuable opportunities while minimizing their financial risk.
Remember that in short sales, patience is essential, but so is vigilance. With proper planning and professional guidance, your earnest money can remain secure throughout even the lengthiest short sale process.
Related Posts
What Is a Short Sale? Plain English Guide, Process, Pros and Cons
Learn what a short sale is and how it can help you avoid foreclosure. This guide covers the process, benefits, and potential pitfalls to ensure a smooth transaction.
How to Handle Offers on Short Sales: Primary, Backups, and Earnest Money
Learn how to handle offers on short sales effectively. This guide covers strategies for primary buyers, backup offers, and earnest money to protect your clients and streamline the process.
Made with Bullet